New Delhi
Rahul Gandhi‘s defence of India’s strategic ties with Israel — including arms purchases — during a university interaction in the United States has opened a rift inside the opposition INDIA bloc, with two Left allies accusing him of double standards on Gaza even as Congress leaders rallied behind him.
The Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha made the remarks on Wednesday, 18 November, during an interaction with political scientist Robert Pape at the University of Chicago, titled “The Iran War & India’s Role in the World”. The discussion was part of a two-day visit to the United States that also took him to Columbia University in New York a day earlier. Within days, the comments had drawn sharp responses from the Communist Party of India (Marxist-Leninist) Liberation and the Communist Party of India (Marxist) — both partners of the Congress in the INDIA bloc — turning a foreign-policy remark made abroad into a political row at home.
What Gandhi said in Chicago

Asked about India-Israel ties, Gandhi said there were strategic reasons for the relationship and defended continued defence purchases from Israel. “As far as [our] relationship with Israel goes, there are strategic reasons why we have a relationship with them… We have to buy the best weapons, and they happen to produce very good weapons,” he said.
He went further, arguing that the size of the country should shape its foreign policy. “We have good relations with Israel, and we buy weapons from them. But we are a much bigger country, with a population of 1.5 billion, and our foreign policy should be based on what is good for us, not on what is good for others,” he said during the interaction.
Sharing a video of the discussion on social media afterwards, Gandhi restated his position in his own words. “India’s foreign policy must be guided by what is good for India. I support a strong relationship with Israel. We have strategic interests, including buying the best weapons for our armed forces. But that cannot mean silence on Gaza. I condemn the October 7th attacks and the killing of innocent people. I also condemn what Israel has done in Gaza. One wrong cannot justify another,” he wrote.
He also used the interaction to argue that India needed to take a larger role in world affairs and that its foreign policy should be driven by national interest rather than the priorities of other countries. During the same discussion, he said India had become a “side player” in international affairs, pointing to the role Pakistan had played in negotiations between the United States and Iran.
Allies hit back: ‘hypocrisy’ charge
The sharpest criticism came not from the ruling party but from the Congress’s own allies. CPI(ML) Liberation general secretary Dipankar Bhattacharya said India could not pursue an independent foreign policy while maintaining strong strategic ties with Israel, and demanded an end to the partnership.
“Israel today is a genocidal regime and there can be no strategic relationship with a state and a regime that goes on perpetrating a genocide of children, women and common people despite global condemnation. Just as there could be no strategic relationship with Nazi Germany or the Apartheid state of South Africa, there can be no normalising, condoning or downplaying of the Genocide in Gaza…,” Bhattacharya wrote in a social media post. He said India’s existing strategic relationship with Israel had already damaged its foreign policy credibility and added that it must not be rationalised in the name of defence or national security needs. He also said India must stand with the “global voice of justice, freedom and peace” and do everything possible on the foreign policy front to “punish war criminals and not embolden them”.
CPI(M) leader Pinarayi Vijayan joined the criticism a day later, saying Gandhi’s remarks exposed the Congress party’s “glaring hypocrisy on Palestine”. In a social media post on Saturday, Vijayan wrote that at a time when Gaza was witnessing one of the most devastating genocides of our time, with thousands of innocent children among its victims, Gandhi was openly advocating stronger ties and arms purchases from a state responsible for their slaughter. He called Gandhi’s attempt to strike a diplomatic balance in the face of the catastrophe “indefensible” and said the position undermined the foreign policy legacy of former Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, whose foreign policy stood firmly against imperialism and in solidarity with the Palestinian struggle.
The term at the centre of the argument has acquired legal weight in recent years — the International Court of Justice has ruled on genocide claims against Myanmar over the Rohingya — which is one reason the allies’ choice of words has sharpened the debate.
Congress leaders defend the stand
Within the Congress, several leaders defended Gandhi’s position, describing it as an assertion of India’s independent foreign policy and strategic interests. Their argument, in essence, is the one Gandhi himself made in Chicago: that the relationship with Israel serves India’s defence needs, and that maintaining it does not prevent India from speaking out on Gaza.
The defence also rests on the second half of Gandhi’s remarks, which his critics have played down — his explicit condemnation of both the October 7, 2023 attacks and Israel’s actions in Gaza, and his insistence that one wrong cannot justify another. For his supporters, that pairing is the point: strategic cooperation on the one hand, and an independent voice on civilian suffering on the other.
The wider US visit
The Israel remarks were not the only part of the US visit to draw fire. At Columbia University in New York on Tuesday, Gandhi described the Indian economy as sitting on a disaster, citing widespread unemployment and shortcomings in the education system. BJP national president Nitin Nabin hit back, saying the problem lay in Gandhi’s own mindset and his inability to recognise the country’s development, and cited the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund, which have put India’s growth at 7.1 per cent despite global uncertainty. The Confederation of All India Traders also criticised Gandhi over his remarks alleging that demonetisation and the goods and services tax regime had damaged small traders, accusing him of politicising the trading community’s concerns.
Days earlier, the BJP had also criticised Gandhi over his swipe at Prime Minister Narendra Modi following a rare three-way meeting of the leaders of the United States, China and Russia, calling him “clueless on geopolitics”. The exchange underlines how closely every remark from the US visit has been watched — and answered — back home.
A relationship that goes back to 1992
The argument over the Israel relationship is not new. India established full diplomatic relations with Israel in January 1992, under the government of Prime Minister P. V. Narasimha Rao, while continuing to support Palestinian rights and a two-state solution. Defence cooperation has been a central pillar of the relationship ever since, and successive governments have balanced close ties with Israel against India’s traditional support for the Palestinian cause.
What has changed is the political context. Gaza has become one of the most divisive questions in Indian politics, and the INDIA bloc — built to present a united opposition — has never had a single agreed line on it. Gandhi’s Chicago remarks, and the allies’ public response, have now put that disagreement on record.
What happens next
The exchange leaves the opposition bloc with a public foreign-policy disagreement to manage. Whether the allies press the matter further, or the Congress issues a fuller clarification of its position, will decide how long the row runs. For now, the lines are drawn: Gandhi and his defenders argue that national interest must guide foreign policy, while his allies argue that some relationships cannot be justified in the name of national interest at all. The debate is unlikely to end with this week’s exchanges.
Disclaimer: This report is based on available sources and verification. If any fact is found to be incorrect, a correction will be published.
