New Delhi Bureau
Nikhil Gupta sentenced to 235 months in a United States federal court in New York — 19 years and seven months in prison — for his role in a foiled murder-for-hire plot targeting Khalistani separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, closing a case that has strained relations between Washington and New Delhi for three years.
A sentence at the bottom of the guidelines range
United States District Judge Victor Marrero handed down the 235-month sentence at a hearing in Manhattan federal court on Friday, November 20, after a hearing that lasted almost 80 minutes. Gupta, 55, had pleaded guilty in February this year to three charges: murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire, and conspiracy to commit money laundering.
Prosecutors with the Manhattan US Attorney’s office had recommended a sentence of about 24 years in prison. The headline figure is stark: Nikhil Gupta sentenced to 235 months in prison, at the very bottom of the guidelines range of 235 to 293 months. The defence had argued that the plot never came to fruition and that Gupta has no criminal record in India, and it urged the court to punish him only for what he did.
“This case cuts to the very core of American values,” prosecutor Ashley Nicolas told the court. “We don’t condone the use of violence to silence voices in this country, ever.”
The guilty plea and the plot that never happened
According to court papers and the United States Department of Justice, Gupta worked with associates in India and elsewhere in 2023 to arrange Pannun’s assassination in the United States. Pannun is a dual US-Canadian citizen and a lawyer with the group Sikhs for Justice in New York, who has advocated for a sovereign Sikh state in northern India.
Prosecutors said Gupta and his co-defendant, Vikash Yadav, whom they identified as an Indian government employee, agreed to pay 100,000 dollars for Pannun’s murder. Gupta arranged a 15,000-dollar advance payment to a purported hitman who was, in fact, an undercover United States law enforcement officer. Yadav has also been charged in the case but is not in American custody.
Gupta was arrested in Prague in June 2023 and was later extradited to the United States, where he has been held without bail since. In February 2026 he pleaded guilty to all three charges, admitting that he had orchestrated the failed plot. A plea agreement had called for him to serve at least two decades in prison.
“I’m sorry to Mr. Pannun” — an apology in court
Addressing the court before he was sentenced, Gupta said he regretted straying from the nonviolent example set by Indian independence leader Mahatma Gandhi. “I’m sorry to Mr. Pannun, I’m sorry to the communities I hurt, I’m sorry to my own family, which always loved me, even when I did not deserve it,” he said.
His family, whom he has not seen since before his arrest three years ago, listened to the sentence through an internet link from India.
Gupta’s lawyer, Isabelle Kirshner, told the court that her client was not the mastermind of the operation. “There is no question he was not the brains behind this operation,” she said, describing Gupta as a hardworking husband and father who had volunteered at an orphanage and an animal shelter before he became involved in the plot. She urged Judge Marrero to craft a sentence that punished Gupta only for what he did, “not as a rebuke to India”.
Kirshner also denied that Gupta was involved in the killing of Hardeep Singh Nijjar in Canada, and she described his recorded discussions about assassination attempts in Nepal and Pakistan as “pure puffery”. Court papers say Gupta had told the undercover officer that Nijjar’s killing outside a Sikh temple in British Columbia in June 2023 was the work of the same individuals planning Pannun’s assassination, and that Nijjar “was also the target”.
Pannun’s statement and the protest outside
Pannun, who was allowed to address the court as a victim-witness, said he has not been able to carry out his regular legal practice for more than 1,200 days since the threat to his life was uncovered. He said he was grateful to the United States for prosecuting Gupta and that he would keep advocating for Sikh sovereignty. “Self-determination for my people and my homeland, Punjab, is my lifetime goal,” he said.
Pannun described Gupta as “just a foot soldier acting at the behest” of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and alleged that the Modi administration wants him dead. That allegation has not been proved in court, and India has denied any involvement in the plot, as set out below.
Outside the courthouse, supporters of Pannun gathered with yellow and blue flags representing Khalistan. They marched around a makeshift prison cell bearing illustrations of Prime Minister Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah in handcuffs and orange prison jumpsuits. In August, Pannun said the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police had warned him that he faced a new credible threat to his life.
India’s position and a relationship under strain
The discovery of alleged assassination plots against Sikh separatists in the United States and Canada has tested India’s relations with both countries. India’s government has dissociated itself from any plot against Pannun, saying such an act was against government policy.
The case against Yadav, the co-defendant whom American prosecutors have identified as an Indian government employee, remains open. He is not in United States custody, and it is unclear whether he has hired a defence lawyer. The contrast between the two defendants — one convicted and sentenced in an American courtroom, the other charged but beyond its reach — is now the central loose end of the case.
The sentencing also leaves the wider diplomatic questions open. Canada is still investigating Nijjar’s killing, and the United States case has become a reference point in every discussion of how far one state may go against dissidents living on another’s soil. For now, the American court has spoken only about Gupta: a 55-year-old Indian national who admitted his part in a murder-for-hire conspiracy and will spend the next 19 years and seven months in a United States prison.
What happens next
Judge Marrero said Gupta faces deportation to India once he completes his 235-month sentence. The case against Yadav will continue separately, and Pannun has said he will keep advocating for his cause despite the threats against him.
Our earlier report on this case — Nikhil Gupta to be sentenced in New York, with American prosecutors seeking 24 years — is here: https://pradesh24news.in/?p=11949
For the wider diplomatic context, Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s recent address on cultural connectivity at the SCO forum in Delhi is here: https://pradesh24news.in/?p=11954
The Reuters report on the sentencing is here: https://www.reuters.com/world/us/indian-man-sentenced-more-than-19-years-us-plotting-kill-sikh-separatist-2026-11-20/
Disclaimer: This report is based on available sources and verification. If any fact is found to be incorrect, a correction will be published.
